Closing A Credit Card Can Increase Your Credit Utilization Ratio
makes up 30 percent of your FICO credit score. Since your credit utilization ratio is the ratio of your current balances to your available credit, reducing the amount of credit available to you by closing a credit card could cause your credit utilization ratio to go up and your credit score to go down. Many experts suggest consumers maintain a credit utilization at or below 30 percent. A high raises red flags for lenders because it shows youre using a higher amount of the credit you have available.
Does Closing A Credit Card Account Hurt Your Credit Score
When I was younger, I tried to close my unused credit card accounts to boost my credit score. I never carried a balance, but I thought if I had too many credit cards, I wouldnt be eligible for new lines of credit. Years later, I discovered this belief was misguided, and that the truth was far more complicated.
To understand how closing a credit card account can hurt your credit score, it helps to know how the score is calculated. Companies used to review your credit history to determine your creditworthiness, and then decide whether or not to grant you a line of credit. Today, the credit bureaus have boiled your credit history down to a single number, the credit score.
Read Also: Cbc Innovis Credit Inquiry
Alternatives To Closing A Credit Card
if you do not want to cancel or close your credit card and are looking for alternative ways you can remedy the issues that were leading you to want to cancel the card, here are some tips:
if you were cancelling your credit card because of annual fees, you can call your issuer to consider lowering or waiving the annual fee. some companies may be willing to do this to retain their customers.
if you are worried about overspending if you keep the card, put it somewhere secure or you can even pause your credit card account for a few months.
if you rarely use the credit card you wanted to close, you can keep it open by putting a small monthly subscription to your favourite magazine or OTT. however, make sure you don’t forget the payment due date of your credit card and make payments on time.
Recommended Reading: How To Cancel My Experian Credit Report Account
Consider The Timing And Impact On Your Credit
When you close a credit card, your credit score may be affected. It’s helpful to understand that a part of how your credit score is calculated is the length of your accounts and your credit utilization. Your score goes up the more unused credit you have available compared to the debt you have used. When you cancel a card, your available credit goes down, worsening your credit utilization ratio. While this may help you avoid the temptation to overspend or help simplify your bills, you should still keep in mind that this may make it more difficult for you to find financing on large purchases like a car or home. Talk to a financial advisor if you are uncertain about whether you should cancel your card.
Is It Better To Pay A Little On All Credit Cards Or Pay One Off
You’ll make more progress when you pay a lump sum to one credit card each month. Even though you put most of your effort into paying off one credit card, you should continue to make minimum payments on all your other credit cards to avoid late payment penalties and to keep your accounts in good standing.
Don’t Miss: When Do Accounts Fall Off Credit Report
Check Your Credit Report To Ensure The Account Is Closed
You may want to get a free copy of your credit report to make sure the account is marked closed. It will take seven years for any late payments or delinquencies associated with that account to disappear from a credit report. The good news is that good credit history will remain on your credit report longer. A closed account that was in good standing will remain on your credit report for ten years. This will help shift the majority of your credit information to positive as time passes.
Your Balance Matters A Lot
One action that has a major impact, according to the analysis, is raising or lowering your balance. For example, if you opened a credit card and proceeded to increase your overall balance, the data shows your VantageScore fell an average of 14 points in that first month with the card. Conversely, if you lowered your balance after getting that new card, your VantageScore rose an average of 11 points in that first month.
One example of when you might open a new card and lower your balance: a balance transfer. You may sign up for a zero-interest balance transfer credit card, do the transfer and then proceed to pay down your debt without any new spending.
The numbers look similar when closing a card. Increase your balance and your score drops an average of 12 points, but lower your balance and your score jumps an average of 10 points.
|What opening or closing a credit card does to your VantageScore|
|Average score change, increased balance||Average score change, decreased balance|
|Down 12 points||Up 10 points|
Two-thirds of people who open a credit card increase their overall balance within a month of getting that card. Not surprising: People dont generally get credit cards to stick them in a desk immediately. However, more than 4 in 10 people who close a credit card increase their balance on their other credit cards in that first month, leaving them with fewer cards but a higher overall balance.
Read Also: Do Cash Advances Hurt Your Credit Score
How Many Points Can A Credit Score Go Down With A Hard Inquiry
Each hard credit check can bring your score down up to 10 points! However, there will usually be a three to five-point credit score drop in most cases. What does this mean for you? Each credit check you authorize will bring down all three of your credit scores. And so, you should really think about what you are applying for, check out pre-approval , and limit credit checks in a short amount of time.
Add Positive Data To Your Credit Report
There are a couple of fairly new options that may be attractive to help raise your score, like Experian Boost and UltraFICO. These are programs that allow the consumer to supply positive data in their credit report that can be used to increase scores. This is especially effective for people with limited credit histories. Both are simple to use and results are seen instantly.
To use Experian Boost you must allow the credit bureau to access to your banking information in order to pull things like utility and phone bill payments. Positive payment histories are incorporated in your report and can add points to your score.UltraFICO looks at your checking and savings account information for positive data such as how much you have in savings, how active your accounts are and how long they have been open.
Both use only positive data and you can enroll or drop out at any time. Also, both only impact your Experian report, so keep that in mind. If you pay rent to a landlord that does not report to the bureaus, consider using a rent payment service that acts as a middleman when you pay your rent, enabling them to report positive rent payment history on your credit reports.
Also Check: How To Remove Public Records From Credit Report
Is Canceling Your Credit Card Wise
It could be a smart idea to cancel a credit card when it’s costing you too much money or hurting your credit score in other ways. However, as canceling a credit card typically hurts your credit, if you are going to close your card, you can do it in a way that minimizes the damage to your credit file. Weighing the pros and cons can help you make the best choice for your financial situation.
- More From CNET
Length Of Credit History
A longer active credit history is usually better for your credit. In general, lenders like to see that you have a track record of managing credit effectively over time.
But when you close a credit card, that card stops aging and cant grow. That will cut into your active credit history for at least as long as it takes to get another account growing.
And if the card youre thinking of closing was also your first credit card, we strongly recommend keeping it open even if you rarely use it. As your oldest line of credit, it will have the biggest impact on the length of your credit history.
Recommended Reading: How Do You Get A Credit Score
Does Closing A Credit Card Affect Credit
It can, depending on how many other credit accounts you have open and whether or not you use those credit accounts responsibly. Knowing how your credit score works will help you better understand what the credit impact of closing your card might be.
Here are two of the biggest ways in which closing a credit card affects your credit:
It Is The Oldest Account In Your Credit History
Even though they are collecting dust, it may be wise to hold on to your old cards to maintain your credit history. Closing old credit cards can decrease the average age of your account. In fact, the length of the credit history makes up about 15 percent of the credit score.
Closing a credit card can also decrease your overall credit limit and increase your credit utilisation ratio if you maintain the same balance or spending pattern.You have only one or few credit accounts
Cancelling a sole credit card can hurt your credit score too. Over 10 percent of your credit score depends on credit activeness. Having only a few accounts on your credit history may lead to a thin credit report and a lower credit score.
Read Also: How To Clear Your Credit Report
Your Card Has A High Interest Rate
If your card has a high interest rate, it makes sense to avoid carrying a balance on the card. You don’t need to close the card to avoid interest if you make sure to pay off the balance every month or simply don’t use the card.
Make sure you only charge items you can pay off in full to avoid interest and keep the account open. You’ll need to use the card occasionally to avoid having it closed by the card issuer, but it only takes a small charge every once in a while to avoid closure.
Keep The Card For Small Regular Payments
If you dont want to swap, upgrade or downgrade your credit card but arent currently using it, you can keep the account active without much effort. If you choose to keep the credit card open, put one small recurring charge on it every month and set up automatic payments so that your statement balance always gets paid on time. This way, your credit card remains active without much effort on your part.
Don’t Miss: How Long Are Hard Inquiries On Credit Report
Can Canceling Your Card Hurt Your Credit Score
It is possible that canceling your credit card may lower your credit score. Because credit is essential for establishing financial responsibility to lenders, renters, and creditors, maintaining a good credit score is essential. A good credit score is generally considered to be anything above 700. If you have a good credit score, you may not need to worry as much about closing a card. However, many factors affect a credit card score and everyones financial situation is different, so consider the length of your account history, your credit utilization ratio, and any upcoming purchases that will require a good score before canceling a card. Heres a more in-depth list of things to consider before canceling your credit card.
Ways Cancelling A Credit Card Could Hurt Your Credit Score
If your credit history also shows you’ve recently made some late payments or have defaulted on accounts, cancelling your card might hurt your score or leave it unchanged.
- If you have a lot of recent applications. Applying for a lot of credit cards over a few months increases the level of risk for your existing and potential lenders. It may suggest that you’re struggling with debt or that you’re jumping from one credit card to another in order to take advantage of introductory offers. While there’s not technically anything wrong with that, credit card companies do frown on this type of behaviour.
- If it was your only credit account. Cancelling a credit card when you don’t have any other loans or credit accounts limits the amount of information you’ll have on your credit file. That means your credit score could drop or remain unchanged until you apply for a new card.
- If making payments on your other accounts is still a challenge. While cancelling a credit card could be a step in the right direction, you may still find that it’s difficult to make payments on your other accounts. This could lead to more late payments or defaults that lower your credit score. If you need help dealing with your credit accounts, you can get free support by calling Financial Counselling Australia on 1800 007 007 between 9:30am and 4:30pm Monday to Friday .
Recommended Reading: How To Bring My Credit Score Up
How Your Credit Score Is Determined
Your credit score is a number that represents your creditworthiness and is typically impacted by:
- your payment history
- your credit utilization ratethe total of all outstanding balances you currently owe compared to your total credit limits
- the length of your credit history and the average age of your accounts
- whether youve applied for multiple new credit accounts recently
- your mix of credit
Dont Miss: What Mortgage Company Uses Factual Data
What Youll Learn: Whether Or Not Closing A Credit Card Account Will Affect Your Credit Score
EXPECTED READ TIME:9 MINUTES
Perhaps youre ready to part ways with your credit card maybe youre sick of paying the annual fee or youre ready to stop racking up debt. Whatever the reason, youre probably wondering if closing a credit card hurts your credit.
Its not always the case, but closing a credit card can affect your credit score and report, especially if youve held onto the card for a long time. Well help you understand the consequences and benefits of closing a credit card so you can make the best decision.
You May Like: Open Sky Unsecured
You May Like: Do Payday Loans Ruin Your Credit Rating
Why Did My Credit Score Go Up When Nothing Changed
Reduced overall debt: Paying down installment loans such as mortgages or auto loans may feel like “doing nothing” because it’s part of your monthly routine, but each payment reduces the amount you owe. As long as you make your payments on time, your credit scores will tend to increase, even if you do nothing else.
How Many Credit Cards Should You Have
Theres no definite answer to this question, and it largely depends on how you handle your credit cards. Keep low or zero credit card balances, particularly compared to your overall credit limits and the amount of income you earn. If you do so, having several cards wont affect your credit too much or your ability to get a loan or mortgage.
In fact, having more than one card lowers your credit utilization rate because you have more credit available to you. This is great for your credit scores as long as you dont charge up the cards too much.
Don’t Miss: How Long Are Charge Offs On Credit Report
Check How Your Credit Score May Be Affected
If you want to gauge how closing a credit card may affect your , consider online score simulators, such as from Capital One. For instance, CreditWise’s simulator allows you to see how taking certain actions, such as closing a credit card or paying off a balance, might impact your credit score.
When I simulated how closing my oldest credit card would affect my credit score, it only showed a one point decrease from 808 to 807. Keep in mind, the exact effect on your credit score can vary.
Why Do Hard Credit Inquiries Hurt Your Credit Score
When applying for loans, lines of credit, some jobs, or rental agreements, lenders will check your credit score. This is known as a hard credit inquiry. A hard credit inquiry shows that you are applying for credit or something in that realm . And doing so often may be a sign of financial irresponsibility. Because of this application for credit, your credit score will decrease a little bit after each hard credit inquiry.
Also Check: Does Conns Report To Credit Bureau
Keep Your Credit Card In A Different Place
If you casually use your credit card too often, try keeping it in an alternative location. When your card isnt easily accessible, you may find you reach for it less over time. However, make sure you keep your card in a safe place for your own financial security. Storing your card in a locked safe is much better than keeping it in an unlocked sock drawer.
Why You Can Trust Bankrate
At Bankrate we strive to help you make smarter financial decisions. While we adhere to strict editorial integrity, this post may contain references to products from our partners. Here’s an explanation for how we make money. The content on this page is accurate as of the posting date however, some of the offers mentioned may have expired. Terms apply to the offers listed on this page. Any opinions, analyses, reviews or recommendations expressed in this article are those of the authors alone, and have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by any card issuer.
Recommended Reading: How To Increase Your Credit Rating Uk