Saturday, July 20, 2024
HomeDoes Closing An Account Hurt Your Credit Score

Does Closing An Account Hurt Your Credit Score

Closing A Credit Card Wont Impact Your Credit History

Does Closing a Credit Card Hurt Your Credit Score?

You may have heard that closing a credit card causes you to lose credit for the age of the account. That is mostly a myth.

Credit expert John Ulzheimer, formerly of FICO and Equifax, confirms that closing a credit card will not immediately remove it from your credit reports. As long as the credit card remains on your report, you will still get the value of the age of the account in both the FICO and VantageScore branding credit scoring models. The only way to lose the value of the age of the card is if its removed from your reports, Ulzheimer says.

A closed account will remain on your reports for up to seven years or around 10 years . As long as the account is on your reports, it will be factored into the average age of your credit.

Check Your Credit Before Closing An Account

Closing a credit card account can make sense in certain circumstances, but it’s important to understand that it can adversely affect your credit score. Before your close your account, consider taking a look at your to see where you stand and make sure that closing the account won’t leave you with a credit history that’s too thin or too new. While the negative effects of closing a credit card account are usually temporary, it might be worth keeping a long-standing account open if you’re able to.

When Does It Make Sense To Close A Credit Card

Although closing your credit card account once it’s paid off can cause a dip in scores, there are some instances where it still may make sense to do so. If you have more than one credit card and the account in question has an annual fee, it may not make good financial sense to continue paying for a card you no longer use.

And, if you’ve struggled with credit card debt in the past and leaving the account open represents temptation to charge more than you can afford to repay, closing it may be the best decision. Although your scores may decrease initially when you close an account, they typically rebound in a few months if you continue to make your payments as agreed, assuming everything else in your credit history remains positive.

If you decide closing the account is the best option, contact your lender to notify them that you wish to close it and ask whether there are any outstanding charges or fees. Also make sure you won’t lose any rewards you’ve earned before you close the accountor try to use them first. You will also need to notify any company with whom you have set up automatic charges to that account. Finally, you should cut up or shred the card before disposing of it.

Read Also: Does American Express Report Authorized Users To Credit Bureaus

Whats The Best Way To Close A Credit Card

When you cancel a credit card, go into it with a smart strategy to minimize any damage to your credit score. If youre closing more than one credit card account, try to space them out over time.

That way, your credit utilization ratio wont drop overnight. The same advice applies when opening a new credit card account since each new account causes a small score drop for 12 months.

Its also important to avoid canceling a credit card account right before you apply for a mortgage or other loan. Even if your lower credit utilization only makes your score drop by a few points, that can really make a huge difference in which interest rates youre offered by your lender.

The cutoff point for the very best rates is typically 740. If your credit score is right on the line, even a minor change can cause you to lose the very best loan terms.

More Accounts Are Better When Handled Responsibly

Does Opening a Savings Account Affect Your Credit Score?

In general, a larger number of accounts is better for your credit.

I have more than ten credit cards and a mortgage, and my credit score is well over 800 and the best score Ive ever had. Having a lot of accounts is good for my credit only because I handle them responsibly.

Using credit cards is a great way to earn valuable cash back and travel rewards. The key to doing so successfully is following the most important rule of credit cards:

Pay your balance every month in full by the due date.

I was lucky to learn that tidbit from my history teacher, Mrs. Waples, during an off-topic class discussion in high school. But most people dont learn anything about credit in school.

So Im sharing three key credit tips with you now:

  • From this day forward, never miss a payment due date.
  • Work to pay off your balances completely.
  • Never spend more on credit cards than you can afford to pay in full each month.
  • For many people, thats easier said than done. Thats why its important to understand your own credit habits and use tools like automatic payments.

    Another option is just to leave your credit cards in the back of a drawer for emergencies. Just make sure you use them a few times a year to keep them active.

    If you can manage them responsibly and hold onto them, however, more accounts could be better for your credit. Closing an account, even one you dont regularly use, is rarely in your best interest.

    Recommended Reading: How Personal Responsibility Can Affect Your Credit Report

    When Closing A Credit Card Does Affect Your Credit Score

    Thats not to say you should begin closing credit cards with abandon. It is possible to harm your credit by closing an account, but it has nothing to do with your credit history.

    Lenders want to make sure you arent too reliant on credit to cover your expenses. They like to see that youre carrying a small balance relative to the total amount of credit available to you. This is often referred to as your credit utilization ratio, which you can calculate by dividing your total balance owed by the total amount of credit you have available.

    For example, say you have three credit cards:

    If you add up all your balances and then divide by your total credit limit , youll get a credit utilization ratio of about 21 percent.

    How much you owe is one of the biggest factors that affect your credit it accounts for 30 percent of your score. If your utilization ratio gets too high, your score can drop. Though there is no magic number, most experts recommend maintaining a credit utilization ratio of less than 30 percent to avoid any negative impact on your credit. All types of credit are considered, but revolving credit is weighted much more heavily.

    So how does this relate to closing an account? The reason that closing a credit card account affects scores is because when you close it, you lose the available credit on that account, said Griffin. As a result, your utilization rate increases.

    Should You Close Accounts After Paying Off The Debt

    If you are working to improve your credit scores, it’s typically best to leave your credit cards open once they are paid off. Ideally, you should keep those accounts active by making small purchases and paying your balances in full each month.

    This is especially true if you are planning to take out a loan, such as an auto loan or mortgage, in the next three to six months. You’ll want to keep your credit history stable until that credit transaction is complete.

    Also Check: Will Removing Authorized User Hurt Their Credit

    When Should You Close A Credit Card

    Closing a credit card isnt ever going to help your credit score, so you should think twice before you do it. However, there are a few instances when you should go ahead and cancel a card:

    Youre paying an annual fee. If the card charges an annual fee and youre not reaping enough rewards to make the fee worth it, go ahead and close the account.

    Youre struggling to stay out of debt. If youre working hard to pay off debt and youre worried about racking up a bigger credit card balance, its better to close accounts than to leave yourself open to temptation. In fact, its possible to close credit cards that still have balances you just have to work out payment plans with your card issuers.

    You have too many cards to keep track of. Just one charge that goes unnoticed can spiral into a mess of late fees and calls from collectors. Though there are tools you can use to keep tabs on all your accounts, if you dont trust yourself to stay on top of all your cards, its probably best to get rid of any unnecessary accounts.

    Choosing whether to close a credit card is up to you. Often it makes more sense to just leave it open rather than risk any hits to your credit score. But as Griffin pointed out, its always best to base your decisions on what makes the most sense for you financially rather than what might happen to your credit score.

    Closing A Checking Account

    How Does OPENING and CLOSING Credit Cards Affect Your Credit Score?

    So, does closing a bank account hurt your credit? Its important to understand that if you close a checking account with a negative balance still outstanding, this data will be reported to ChexSystems.

    Additionally, if the balance remains outstanding for an extended period of time, banks can send your account to a collection agency. And a collection agency will likely report to a credit bureau, which could impact your .

    You May Like: Credit Score Needed For Les Schwab Account

    If You Do Have An Overdraft

    A personal overdraft is a line of credit in a way that is similar to a credit card. Australian banks will normally report information to credit bureaus about how you conduct your overdraft account. The information may include the date the overdraft was granted, the overdraft limit, how much of the limit youve used, and whether youre keeping up with any agreed repayment schedule.

    You will find it difficult, if not impossible, to close an overdraft account with a negative balance. Your bank will simply refuse to close the account until you have repaid the overdrawn amount and reduced the balance to zero.

    Repaying an overdraft and then closing the account can affect your credit score both positively and negatively:

    • Positive effects arise from the fact that you were granted credit, used it, and repaid what you owed.
    • Negative effects may result from reducing the amount of credit available to you, meaning that your credit utilisation ratio will increase. E.g., if you have an overdraft limit of $10,000 but have repaid it in full, and a credit card with a $10,000 limit on which you owe $5,000, you would be using 25% of your total available credit of $20,000. But if you close the overdraft account your available credit is reduced to $10,000, of which you are now using 50%. You may want to discuss retaining your overdraft limit with your bank and keeping the account open, if you can trust yourself not to run up debt you cannot repay and if the account fees are not too onerous.

    What Happens When Your Bank Closes

    If your banking institution shuts its doors altogether, you’re protected by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation . A bank will likely handle its closure responsibly, giving you plenty of notice and opportunities to transfer your funds to another institution. However, even if it closes suddenly without notice, the FDIC will insure your funds up to $250,000.

    Also Check: Does Zzounds Report To Credit Bureau

    When It’s Better To Keep The Card

    On the flip side, there are certain circumstances when it can be wiser to keep the account open, such as when:

    • It’s the oldest account on your credit report
    • You don’t have many other open credit accounts, which can result in a thin credit file, making it harder to qualify for future credit
    • The only reason you’re canceling it is that you don’t use it very often

    The Average Age Of Your Accounts Will Decrease

    Does Closing a Credit Card Hurt Your Credit Score ...

    The longer you’ve had credit, the better it is for your credit score. Your score is based on the average age of all your accounts, so closing the one that’s been open the longest could lower your score the most. Closing a new account will have less of an impact. To keep your credit score in good standing, it’s important to remember to stick with a low balance that can easily be paid off before your due date.

    You May Like: How To Remove Repossession From Credit Report

    How To Remove Closed Accounts From Credit Report

    In addition to checking for closed account errors, there are also steps you can take to try and remove closed accounts from your credit report. To remove closed accounts from a report, try the following:

    Dispute errors – If you happen to find errors on your credit report, as we briefly mentioned, you can report these errors to the correct credit bureau. They will investigate the claim to confirm the possible error.

    Goodwill letters – In short, this is a letter you write to your credit lender to ask them to remove a closed account from your report history. Its important to note that your lender has no legal obligation to remove closed accounts from your report.

    Be patient- Although you can try to remove a closed account from your report, oftentimes the best plan of action is to wait it out. Closed accounts are always removed at some point, so we suggest reviewing your report will give you a general idea of when they will be removed.

    Note: Having a closed credit card account removed from your credit report is not always the best choice. If the account has a longstanding history of on-time payments, it may serve your credit score better to keep it on your credit report.

    Does Cancelling A Credit Card Hurt Your Credit Score

    Whether you have too many and want to cut back, or youre trying to limit your chances of overspending, weve probably all found ourselves in the situation of trying to decide whether or not we should cancel a . Before jumping the gun, you should first consider how doing so could affect your because it can, and not in a positive way.

    • As a general rule of thumb, its better not to cancel a credit card if you dont need to particularly if its your first credit card or has a high credit limit
    • Cancelling a credit card can affect your total credit limit and history, and potentially ding your credit score. It shouldnt be a spur of the moment decision
    • If youre just looking to avoid an annual fee on an unused card, consider asking your bank if you can switch it to a no fee alternative instead of cancelling
    • Sometimes cancelling a credit card makes sense or is necessary. By following the right steps, you can close an account without harming your credit score long-term
    • Late payments or maxing out your credit card are generally far worse for your credit score when compared to just closing a credit card

    Don’t Miss: How To Remove Repossession From Credit Report

    How Closing Accounts Affects Your Credit History

    Your takes into account several factors, one of which is your . It makes up 15 percent of your credit score, so its important to show you have a track record of borrowing and paying back money. The longer your credit history, the better.

    Contrary to popular belief, you dont immediately lose the history for a credit card when you close it, said Griffin. He explained that when you close an account thats in good standing , credit bureaus keep that account on your for 10 years from the date its reported closed.

    Compare that with negative items such as missed payments, accounts in collection and bankruptcies which generally stay on your report for seven years.

    We keep the good stuff longer than the bad stuff, he said. So unless you took out one credit card many years ago and havent borrowed money since, closing a credit card should have no impact on your credit history.

    Why Closing A Credit Card Account Can Impact Your Credit

    Closing a Credit Card Doesn’t Really Hurt Your Credit Score

    Your , also called your balance-to-credit-limit ratio, is the second most important factor in credit scores. It measures how much of your available revolving credit you’re using at any given time. The lower your utilization rate, the better for your scores.

    If you close a credit card account and still have balances on other cards, those balances will make up a greater percentage of your total available credit limit. To calculate your utilization ratio, divide the total of all your credit card balances by the total of all your credit card limits, then multiply by 100 to get a percentage.

    Also Check: Zzounds My Account

    Since Charge Cards Dont Have An Impact On Your Credit Utilization Ratio Closing Them Doesnt Have This Credit Score Impact However It Does Have An Impact On Your Length Of Credit History

    For instance, if youve had a charge card for nine years, and three credit cards open for 5, 4, and 2 years, your average length of credit history would be five years.

    If you close the charge card, your average length of credit would drop to approximately 3.7 years. On the other hand, if the charge card isnt one of your longest held cards, this could have little to no impact on your score.

    Some credit scoring models will continue to take into consideration the age of closed accounts, as long as they are still on your report.

    Other credit scoring models will exclude the age of an account if its closed.

    The bottom line? It depends on the entirety of your credit picture and when you first established the charge card account.


    Most Popular